Even amid a meltdown in crypto markets, DIY traders who came of age after the financial crisis no longer want to play by the old rules
Author of the article:
Financial Times
Madison Darbyshire in New York
Inflation and rising interest rates have shaken the cryptocurrency markets in recent months. Photo by JUSTIN TALLIS/AFP via Getty Images files With $1,000 in savings and two United States government stimulus checks, Chris Zettler began investing in 2020. First, he bought companies he knew, he said, “but then I got bored with it.” He moved on to call options in companies with volatile share-prices, riding the price swings. He used a win to buy 100 shares in the meme stock AMC Entertainment Holdings Inc. at US$30 in May and sold at about US$65 in June.
Advertisement 2 This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.
The 35-year-old finance major at the University of Alabama, Birmingham, had a TD Ameritrade account that allowed him to trade on margin (borrowing money from the brokerage to amplify potential returns) and place nearly US$8,000 in bets with his original US$4,000 of capital. He turned that into US$18,000.
Zettler saw his account balance rise to US$50,000 before falling to US$35,000 when a bet went sideways. He sold US$20,000 of shares and paid his college tuition fees: “I got lucky as heck,” he said.
Yet the risk was worth it, he added. The possibility of making outsized returns outweighed the risk of loss: “If I did it again, would I have done it the responsible way and just sat on that $4,000? Shoot, no …You don’t have anything to lose so you might as well shoot your shot.”
Advertisement 3 This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.
Zettler is part of a generation of investors who came of age around the 2008 financial crisis and its aftermath. Having struggled to accumulate wealth through traditional means over the past decade, many have turned to speculating in the riskier corners of financial markets.
A lot of people view it like they can’t afford not to
Chris Zettler
Experts say the growing appetite for speculative assets such as cryptocurrencies, non-fungible tokens (NFTs) and meme stocks (whose value skyrocketed in early 2021, driven by retail traders and social media hype) is about more than just getting rich quick.
Stagnant wages, rock bottom interest rates, soaring house prices — and now, corrosive inflation — have cut away at the idea that the under-40s can follow the well-trodden path to financial security that their parents took. Younger investors report feeling like the game is rigged and that playing by the old rules is a losing strategy.
Advertisement 4 This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.
In recent months, a combination of inflation and rising interest rates have shaken the cryptocurrency markets. Crashing coin prices and the high-profile bankruptcies of crypto lenders and hedge funds have exposed the dangerous practices that flourished in the riskiest areas of the market. The question now is whether the younger DIY investors will retreat.
Zettler’s experience suggests not. He has watched his peers chase desperate bets on cryptocurrencies and volatile stocks hoping to ride the next wave to riches. “A lot of people view it like they can’t afford not to,” he said. “I think they’re running out of hope.”
Fear, uncertainty and doubt Natasha Schüll, a cultural anthropologist at New York University, blames the increased appetite for risk on a widespread disillusionment with the notion that economic success is accessible to anyone who works hard enough. Part of the appeal of cryptocurrencies and meme-stock runs is that they are anti-establishment, designed to operate outside the rules of the traditional financial system.
This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.
Article content “The idea that the mainstream economy is trustworthy, more so than these other (assets), is kind of dubious in recent experience,” she said.
The appetite for high-risk speculation is particularly sharp among Americans, who tend to have high levels of personal debt, researchers say. The average U.S. student now graduates with US$37,000 in student debt, up from US$17,000 in 2001.
There isn’t enough financial stability at the core of people’s lives
Caitlin Zaloom
“The idea is that you’re supposed to be able to save money for college, but almost no middle-class family can in a significant way,” said Caitlin Zaloom, a professor of social and cultural analysis at NYU. “There isn’t enough financial stability at the core of people’s lives. If there was, there would be little incentive to speculate.”
This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.
Article content Rent rises have outpaced income growth in most U.S. states since 2001, according to estimates by the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities. And inflation has pushed the cost of living higher in recent months. As low interest rates and heavy debt became a fact of life, relationships with risk changed, experts say. Young investors are less likely to approach speculative financial products as investments with underlying value. Rather, they are inclined to treat them like lottery tickets: probably worthless, but still worth the gamble on a life-changing payout.
“If you had lottery tickets for houses, investors would buy some of those, too,” said Jeremy Grantham, co-founder of the Boston-based asset management group GMO LLC. “There is enormous inequality, and when people get fed up … they start to behave in strange and new ways.”
This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.
Article content ‘Bored Ape #8971’, part of the Bored Ape Yacht Club collection of 10,000 computer-generated cartoon apes which are traded in the form of NFT. Photo by Benoit Bosc/Handout via REUTERS The logic is simple, said Ben Johnson, head of exchange traded fund research at data provider Morningstar Inc.: “Negative real yields? No thank you. What are the alternatives? JPEGs of monkeys and fake internet money? It’s not surprising that investors feel like they’re stuck between NFT pet rocks and a hard place.”
The discontent isn’t limited to the U.S. A majority of British 35-year-olds surveyed by the insurance company Urban Jungle Services Ltd. reported feeling at an “unfair disadvantage to the generations directly before them” when it comes to financial stability and savings.
Gary Stevenson, a 35-year-old former trader and financial education campaigner from east London, is one: “My dad never went to university. He worked at the post office for 35 years and could raise three kids and pay off (a mortgage) … he has a comfortable retirement,” he said. “That is off the table for most young people now. It’s created a bit of a panic.”
This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.
Article content He added: “If you can’t do what your dad or grandad did … you have to come up with a better plan.” At some point, risky bets start to look like the rational choice: “One way, you see a zero-per-cent chance of success. But if you take on insane risk … at least you have a chance.”
To the moon A person walks past a GameStop Corp. store in the Manhattan borough of New York City. Photo by REUTERS/Carlo Allegri/File Photo During the meme-stock frenzy of early 2021, stories of huge returns fuelled a rush of new trading. Some people won big. An investor who bought GameStop Corp. in late December 2020 could have turned 10,000 pounds into 168,744 pounds in a single month when the meme stock hit its peak on Jan. 29, 2021 — an almost 1,600 per cent gain. But there was also the potential for huge losses: an investor who bought at the top and then sold in late February would have shrunk the same 10,000 pounds into 3,129 pounds in a month, following a 69 per cent plunge, according to Boring Money Ltd. analysis.
This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.
Article content Even so, many young investors reject the “dumb money” label applied to their trades. They say the odds are worth the punt, given the alternatives. Many investors remember the unequal recovery from the 2008 crisis when government bailouts, followed by a decade-long bull run in markets, left the uninvested behind. When markets tumbled as COVID-19 hit in March 2020, they didn’t want to miss out a second time. New technology meant there was never an easier time to get involved.
The introduction of commission-free trading in stocks in the run-up to the pandemic added momentum to lottery-like investing behaviour. In 2015, the zero-commission brokerage Robinhood Markets Inc. was launched, promising to “democratize” financial markets. Four years later, almost every U.S.-based broker had eliminated commissions for equity trading. Robinhood’s game-like app allows customers to sign up and start trading stocks on their phones within minutes.
This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.
Article content Slick cryptocurrency exchanges such as Coinbase emerged as the number of digital coins on the market exploded. A “meme coin” craze driven by super-influencers such as Elon Musk introduced an avalanche of outlandish offerings, from those named after celebrities (Coinye West) to the “dog coins” Shiba Inu and dogecoin. In April 2013, there were just seven cryptocurrencies available for mining and trading. Today, there are tens of thousands.
Getting involved was simple. “It’s five buttons on the website,” said Luke Hawley, a 21-year-old going into his senior year at Endicott College in Massachusetts who studies finance. “It’s easier to buy Shiba Inu on Coinbase than buy an index.”
Monitors display Coinbase signage during the company’s initial public offering at the Nasdaq MarketSite in New York. Photo by Michael Nagle/Bloomberg files Hawley said it has become normal on his college campus to talk about betting and speculating. “People think, ‘OK, I’ve got a couple thousand in the bank. In the real world, that’s, like, broke,’” he said. “There’s a lot of FOMO,” he added, about the idea of passing over a chance to turn a small stake into big money.
This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.
Article content Young men in particular have been attracted to this kind of moonshot investing. The vast majority of cryptocurrency investors are men and more than 90 per cent of trades in GameStop and AMC were made by men during the peak of the meme-stock frenzy, according to the United Kingdom brokerage Interactive Investor Services Ltd. Experts say one reason these investments are treated like casual bets is because the brokerage apps feel like gambling platforms, only without the regulatory guardrails.
“Increasingly, platforms are blurring the line between gaming, gambling and investing, especially platforms that enable the use of cryptocurrency,” said Jack Symons, chief executive of the U.K. app Gamban, which allows users to block gambling apps on their phones and computers.
This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.
Article content It’s easier to buy Shiba Inu on Coinbase than buy an index
Luke Hawley
Gamban began to block brokerage and crypto platforms last summer. “Some might say this is a blunt approach, but gambling doesn’t look like it used to. It’s not something that only happens (in a casino) on green felt,” Symons said in October.
Late last year, the largest American gambling hotline told the Financial Times it was seeing a marked increase in the number of calls coming from people addicted to day trading, rather than traditional gambling or sports betting. One reason might be that, as Stevenson said, investing does not carry the same social stigma as gambling.
“If you said, ‘My dad spends all day gambling,’ (I’d) say, ‘Oh man, I’m so sorry for your family,’” he said. But “if someone says, ‘My dad spends all day FX trading,’ you think he’s the Wolf of Wall Street … It’s not gambling, it’s investing, and investing is how you get rich.”
This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.
Article content Diamond hands In recent months, as the air has rushed out of the cryptocurrency balloon, the most speculative parts of the market have been hardest hit. But as prices crashed, attempts by some crypto companies to persuade investors to keep faith and hold on through what they dismissed as just another cyclical “crypto winter” shows the growing power of online communities.
The under-25s are twice as likely to turn to social media for financial advice than any other age group, and more than three times as likely to do so than to seek help from a professional, according to a survey by U.K. advisory OpenMoney Adviser Services Ltd.
Robinhood’s rise happened as online communities on Twitter and Reddit began to play a bigger role in investing. Reddit subforums such as r/WallStreetBets provided specialist information for would-be investors, facilitated their discussions and plucked at their heartstrings.
This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.
Article content The logo of Robinhood Markets, Inc. at a pop-up event on Wall Street after the company’s IPO in New York City. Photo by REUTERS/Andrew Kelly/File Photo Big losses could be laughed off with peers and big gains shared and celebrated. Those who held their nerve were lauded for their hubris: “diamond hands” became the emoji vernacular for holding tight to a bold position even when it collapses.
A study by academics at the University of Sydney last year found that people aged between 18 and 24 were much more likely to make risky decisions when they thought their peers were watching. Agnieszka Tymuła, the lead researcher on the study, said online communities of investors amplify the same behaviour: “People want to take risks, to get that big win and post about it.”
The illusion of control also amplifies risk taking. Whether by laying out the specifics of niche cryptocurrencies, or discussing “moonshot” strategies, web forums encourage members to feel that the odds of winning are significantly greater than they actually are. Regulation has not kept up with the spread of misinformation.
This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.
Article content People want to take risks, to get that big win and post about it
Agnieszka Tymuła
Some college students say they are increasingly familiar with the dangers of cryptocurrency pump-and-dump schemes such as so-called rug-pulls — when a developer launches a crypto asset, drives the price up via social-media influencers and then disappears with their gains before the price collapses.
“It’s not pretty being on the back end of a rug-pull,” said Harrison Turner, a 19-year-old rising college junior from Montgomery, Ala. Still, he said, he understands the influencer’s motivation: “He saw an opportunity and he took it.”
Get rich slow Despite the increasingly hostile investing environment, high-risk speculation may be here to stay. “It worked spectacularly well for some people, and old habits die hard,” said Steve Sosnick, chief strategist at U.S. trading platform Interactive Brokers LLC. “They’re still using margin to speculate, even as rates go up.”
This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.
Article content In May, the amount of money borrowed to trade on margin was 25 per cent above pre-pandemic levels, data from the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) shows.
Traditional wealth managers are uneasy about the prospect of digital assets going mainstream. Nearly half of fund selectors said they feel pressure to offer cryptocurrencies to attract younger investors, according to research by Natixis Investment Managers. Yet 70 per cent said they think individuals should not have exposure to the volatile asset.
“Cryptocurrency is not the systemic solution to income inequality,” said Georgia Lee Hussey, a wealth manager and founder of Modernist Financial LLC. “If your investing strategy is sexy, you’re doing it wrong.”
This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.
Article content Noah Solomon: Why the Fed might not save stock markets this time If you’re reacting to volatility after it occurs, you’re already behind Five reasons the investment industry may work against some investors Brokerages are also worried that investors burnt by big losses could retreat from markets entirely, reinforced in their view that the game is rigged. Attempts to educate potential clients means reaching investors where they are — on social platforms. Fidelity Investments Inc. has embraced both digital assets and social media outreach in an effort to connect with investors and convince them it is possible to get rich slow.
“Young investors report that their top concern is their financial security, how to have enough to be ‘OK,’” said Kelly Lannan, head of emerging customers at Fidelity. “It’s very basic … We hear that more with this generation.”
Advertisement 18 This advertisement has not loaded yet, but your article continues below.
While Zettler said he has become more “boring” with his investments, others such as Turner are still comfortable risking it all. He has already lost his brokerage funds once by mistiming a meme-stock bet, but said he can always earn enough to put a few thousand dollars in a brokerage account. “The money will come and go,” he said. He knows he could lose it all.
Then again, he said, he could get lucky.
The Financial Times Ltd.
_____________________________________________________________
If you like this story, sign up for the FP Investor Newsletter.
_____________________________________________________________
Financial Post Top Stories Sign up to receive the daily top stories from the Financial Post, a division of Postmedia Network Inc.
By clicking on the sign up button you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. You may unsubscribe any time by clicking on the unsubscribe link at the bottom of our emails. Postmedia Network Inc. | 365 Bloor Street East, Toronto, Ontario, M4W 3L4 | 416-383-2300