In the 12 months ending June 30, companies in the S&P 500 index spent a record $1 trillion to buy back their own shares, according to S&P Dow Jones Indices. But come January, a new 1% tax on buybacks might dampen corporate America’s appetite. S&P Dow Jones estimates the tax would reduce corporate profits by half a percentage point at current buyback rates.
Buybacks have lately become controversial, with critics arguing that there are better uses for corporate cash. But a 2020 S&P Dow Jones Indices analysis of the 100 companies with the biggest buybacks found that their long-term stock returns generally outpaced the S&P 500.
Many smart investors, including Warren Buffett, are big supporters of strategic buybacks. “If a management wishes to further intensify our ownership by repurchasing shares, we applaud,” he has said.
Subscribe to Kiplinger’s Personal Finance Be a smarter, better informed investor.
Save up to 74%
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free E-Newsletters Profit and prosper with the best of Kiplinger’s expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more – straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of Kiplinger’s expert advice – straight to your e-mail.
The new tax is low enough that it will discourage only the most marginal buybacks, say experts, so don’t expect them to disappear. But buybacks can be complex to evaluate. For investors trying to navigate this changing market, a few signals can help you find stocks likely to benefit from share repurchases despite the tax. But first, the basics.
The pros. Buybacks make a lot of sense when a company can sweep up shares whose prices have been irrationally driven below true value by market swings. Such purchases signal insiders’ faith in the company and add demand that supports the stock’s price.
Many investors prefer buybacks over dividends because although you must pay taxes on dividends when they are issued, you don’t pay capital gains taxes until you sell your shares. In addition, when companies buy back more shares than they issue, each remaining share represents a bigger ownership slice of the company
Some investors want companies to distribute cash through buybacks so managers aren’t tempted to make worse choices, says Meb Faber, chief investment officer of Cambria Investment Management. “How many companies have wasted money on naming stadiums?”
Executives like buybacks because by reducing the number of shares outstanding, a company can report higher per-share earnings even when overall profits are flat or down. That can be an especially enticing strategy for any executive whose compensation is tied to rising earnings per share.
Buybacks also give managers flexibility. A company that raises its dividend risks a stock meltdown if troubles later force it to cut the payout. A buyback program, however, can usually be suspended without alarming investors. Another advantage: Every share brought home means one less dividend payment for those companies that also pay dividends, reducing future cash obligations.
Finally, economists like buybacks because they take cash from companies that lack good internal investment ideas and return it to shareholders—who then typically reinvest it in other publicly traded companies (which, presumably, have more-productive investment plans).
Swipe to scroll horizontally
In recent years, companies in the S&P 500 index have preferred to return cash to shareholders via share buybacks rather than by paying dividends.YearShare Buybacks (billions)Dividends (billions)2022 (through June 30)$501$2782021882511202052048320197294852018806456The cons. Politicians as disparate as senators Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) and Marco Rubio (R-Fla.) have tried to discourage buybacks. The critics hope to nudge companies to invest more in their operations, generating new jobs.
Although some studies highlight the positive aspects of buybacks, others conclude that shareholders often benefit more from alternative uses of cash. Greg Milano, CEO of Fortuna Advisors, an investment consulting firm, says Fortuna found over the past 12 years that, on average, firms that raised earnings per share due to investments in operations generated twice the stock-price gain of companies that raised per-share profits through buybacks. Dividend payouts also led to slightly higher returns than did buybacks.
And Milano warns that despite the hype, many buybacks don’t end up giving investors a bigger share of a company because companies often issue more shares in stock-based compensation plans than they repurchase. Worst of all, investors have been burned by companies that spent billions on buybacks instead of cleaning up their balance sheets or investing in their businesses to protect against downturns—as some airlines did recently, for example. (For more on airlines, see Why Airline Stocks Are a Bad Deal)
How to cash in. Investors who still want to ride the coattails of buyback programs should follow three principles, experts say. The stocks mentioned below provide good examples.
Avoid dilution. Don’t jump at every buyback announcement. Check whether the company’s overall share count is actually decreasing, thereby raising your ownership stake in the company, advises Faber. You can look up a company’s outstanding shares in its Securities and Exchange filings, or you can find its most recent share count on websites such as Yahoo Finance and YCharts. A good example is McKesson (MCK (opens in new tab)), says Faber, whose investment firm owns the stock. The distributor of drugs and medical supplies has reduced its share count by 7% in the past year, and over the past five years the stock price has doubled.
Look for price discipline. Successful repurchasers, like successful investors, should buy low. Buffett’s Berkshire Hathaway (BRK.B (opens in new tab)), sitting on more than $100 billion in cash, buys back its own shares when the price falls below what Buffett calls its “intrinsic value.” Morningstar sector strategist Greggory Warren notes that the company has repurchased $58 billion worth of its common stock since 2019, reducing its share count by about 10%. Warren, a Berkshire bull, believes the company is focused on reducing its long-standing cash hoard through a mix of stock purchases and share buybacks.
Bet on healthy firms. Fortuna’s Milano says the companies most likely to have high long-term returns on their buybacks have strong balance sheets and, ideally, are less vulnerable than other firms to economic or commodity cycles. One company high on his list: Apple (AAPL (opens in new tab)). Since the start of 2021, Apple has bought back more than $200 billion of its stock, reducing its share count by about 5%. In that time, the stock has gained roughly 6%, not including dividends, compared with a loss of 3% for the S&P 500 index. Says Howard Silverblatt, senior index analyst for S&P Dow Jones Indices, “Apple is the poster child for buybacks.”